Determinism


Determinism
   Karl Marx’s theory of historical materialism, his predictions (for example concerning the increasing immiserization of the poor and the collapse of capitalism), and Marxist laws of history/ capitalism all lead to the issue of determinism. Within Marxism this issue concerns the extent to which events are inevitable, predictable and alterable.
   One interpretation of historical materialism that constituted the orthodoxy within the Marxist movement at the end of the 19th and beginning of the 20th century has come to be known as economic determinism. This view, associated particularly with Karl Kautsky and the Second International, asserted that the ultimately determining factor in history and society was the economic base. Within the economic base, according to this view, the forces of production, or more narrowly still technology, determined the relations of production, and these in turn (possibly in combination with the forces of production) determined the character of society as a whole. Hence, a change in technology or the forces of production would ultimately change the character of the whole of society. Kautsky and his followers saw the collapse of capitalism and the advent of communism as inevitable, and all that Marxists and the labor movement could do was to help hasten this eventuality. Georgii Plekhanov, who similarly approached Marxism from a determinist perspective, suggested in his The Role of the Individual in History (1908) that individuals did have an active role to play in shaping history, but they could not change the general trend of history.
   However, other Marxists, even when acknowledging a determinist aspect to Marx’s writings, have suggested the role of human agency is much greater than the economic determinism of the Second International approach allows. The school of Western Marxism, the Marxist humanists, and Jean-Paul Sartre in particular have suggested nondeterminist interpretations, and Mao Zedong and Chinese Marxism with such slogans as “Politics in Command” have put forward a much more voluntarist interpretation of Marxism. There remains, though, a genuine ambiguity in Marx’s writings with regard to the inevitability of the collapse of capitalism and its replacement by communism, and about the extent to which human action can influence the course of history.
   As regards the predictability of events, Kautsky, Plekhanov and Eduard Bernstein all take the scientific status of Marxism seriously and their interpretation of science is strongly colored by positivism. This means they understand Marxism as a theory that is capable of generating predictions, but other Marxists and a close reading of Marx both indicate this interpretation to be wrong.

Historical dictionary of Marxism. . 2014.

Look at other dictionaries:

  • Determinism — • A name employed by writers, especially since J. Stuart Mill, to denote the philosophical theory which holds, in opposition to the doctrine of free will, that all man s volitions are invariably determined by pre existing circumstances Catholic… …   Catholic encyclopedia

  • determinism — DETERMINÍSM s.n. Teorie, concepţie potrivit căreia fenomenele sunt generate de înlănţuiri de cauze şi efecte, prin condiţionări şi legităţi prin interacţiuni necesare şi repetitive. – Din fr. déterminisme. Trimis de IoanSoleriu, 01.09.2004. Sursa …   Dicționar Român

  • determinism —    Determinism concerning human beings is the thesis that every action performed by a human is determined, that is, antecedently caused or fixed, by something else. The something else might be another agent, one s genes, one s upbringing, a prior …   Christian Philosophy

  • Determinism — De*ter min*ism, n. (Metaph.) The doctrine that the will is not free, but is inevitably and invincibly determined by motives, preceding events, and natural laws. [1913 Webster] Its superior suitability to produce courage, as contrasted with… …   The Collaborative International Dictionary of English

  • Determinism — (biological) …   Philosophy dictionary

  • determinism — 1846, in theology (lack of free will); 1876 in general sense of doctrine that everything happens by a necessary causation, from Fr. déterminisme, from Ger. Determinismus, perhaps a back formation from Praedeterminismus (see DETERMINE (Cf.… …   Etymology dictionary

  • determinism — [dē tʉr′mi niz΄əm, ditʉr′mi niz΄əm] n. the doctrine that everything, including one s choice of action, is the necessary result of a sequence of causes determinist n., adj. deterministic adj. deterministically adv …   English World dictionary

  • Determinism — This article is about the general notion of determinism in philosophy. For other uses, see Determinism (disambiguation). Not to be confused with Fatalism, Predeterminism, or Predictability. Certainty series …   Wikipedia

  • determinism — determinist, n., adj. deterministic, adj. deterministically, adv. /di terr meuh niz euhm/, n. 1. the doctrine that all facts and events exemplify natural laws. 2. the doctrine that all events, including human choices and decisions, have… …   Universalium

  • determinism — also known as soft determinism and championed by Hume, is a theory which holds that free will and determinism are compatible. According to Hume, free will should not be understood as an absolute ability to have chosen differently under exactly… …   Mini philosophy glossary


Share the article and excerpts

Direct link
Do a right-click on the link above
and select “Copy Link”

We are using cookies for the best presentation of our site. Continuing to use this site, you agree with this.